The best hotels in Italy
Italy is the country our readers return to most — and the one where the choice of hotel changes the trip most completely. A room above the Amalfi water, a converted monastery in Tuscany, a Dolomites house of glass and larch: each is a different Italy.
These are the Italian places in our collection, ranked by what verified guests actually scored them, not by what their press kits say.
Where to stay in Italy
- Hotel Pellegrino — Praiano, Amalfi Coast, Italy · 9.9/10 from 191 verified reviews
- Palazzo Portinari Salviati — Florence, Italy · 9.9/10 from 156 verified reviews
- Hotel Miramalfi — Amalfi, Amalfi Coast, Italy · 9.8/10 from 335 verified reviews
- La Monastica Resort & Spa — Borgo a Buggiano, Tuscany, Italy · 9.8/10 from 227 verified reviews
- Santre dolomythic home — Bressanone, South Tyrol, Italy · 9.7/10 from 1704 verified reviews
- Castelfalfi — Montaione, Tuscany, Italy 🇮🇹 · 9.7/10 from 625 verified reviews
- ADLER Spa Resort Sicilia — Sicily, Italy · 9.7/10 from 328 verified reviews
- Lefay Resort & SPA Dolomiti — Pinzolo, Dolomites, Italy · 9.6/10 from 682 verified reviews
- Villa Cortine Palace Relais & Châteaux — Sirmione, Lake Garda, Italy · 9.6/10 from 581 verified reviews
- Boutique Hotel Stresa — Stresa, Lake Maggiore, Italy · 9.6/10 from 241 verified reviews
- Avidea Adults Only — Merano, South Tyrol, Italy · 9.5/10 from 159 verified reviews
- Orient Express La Dolce Vita — Rome to Venice — Rome to Venice, Italy 🇮🇹
When to go
May, June and September are the sweet spot almost everywhere: warm sea, workable light, fewer crowds. The Dolomites and the lakes hold well into October; Sicily stays swimmable later than the mainland.
Destinations within Italy
The Best Hotels in Tuscany
Tuscany does not need another guidebook. It needs a shortlist of the places our readers describe as the best stay of their lives. Looking for the best hotels in Tuscany? 3 places in the Italy collection sit here, each chosen on verified guest scores rather than press material — Late April through June and mid-September through October. The countryside is at its best during harvest — late September to mid-October.
See all 3 places in Tuscany
The Best Hotels on the Amalfi Coast
A landscape of vertical citrus groves and ancient maritime towns, the Amalfi Coast remains a cornerstone of the Mediterranean experience. Our collection focuses on the quiet corners of this famous shoreline, where the views are expansive and the pace remains traditionally slow. Looking for the best hotels in the Amalfi Coast? 2 places in the Italy collection sit here, each chosen on verified guest scores rather than press material — Late spring and early autumn offer the most tempered weather and manageable crowds, particularly in May and September. The region becomes difficult to navigate in July and August due to intense heat and congestion, while many establishments close entirely during the quiet, damp winter months.
See all 2 places in The Amalfi Coast
The Best Hotels in Sicily
Sicily is a land of archaeological grandeur and coastal repose, where the passage of time is measured in centuries rather than hours. Looking for the best hotels in Sicily? one place in the Italy collection sit here, each chosen on verified guest scores rather than press material — Spring and early autumn offer the most temperate conditions for exploring ruins and coastal paths without the intense heat of August. The winter months can be surprisingly damp and many seasonal establishments close, while the height of summer brings heavy crowds and temperatures that may limit daytime activity.
See all 1 place in Sicily
The Best Hotels on the Italian Lakes
The Italian Lakes represent a refined intersection of alpine topography and Mediterranean flora, where life is governed by the steady arrival of the ferry. Our collection focuses on properties that capture the quietude of the water and the historic weight of these northern shores. Looking for the best hotels in the Italian Lakes? 2 places in the Italy collection sit here, each chosen on verified guest scores rather than press material — The region is at its most balanced during May and September, when the gardens are in bloom and the humidity remains low. We suggest avoiding the deep winter months of December and January, as many ferry services are suspended and the damp lakeside mist can be pervasive.
See all 2 places in The Italian Lakes
The Best Hotels in the Dolomites & South Tyrol
A landscape of pale limestone spires and high-altitude meadows, the Dolomites offer a refined intersection of Austrian tradition and Italian grace. Our collection focuses on the quiet corners of South Tyrol, where the pace of life slows to the steady rhythm of the mountains. Looking for the best hotels in the Dolomites & South Tyrol? 3 places in the Italy collection sit here, each chosen on verified guest scores rather than press material — June to September offers clear paths for hiking, while January to March provides reliable snow for the ski season. We suggest avoiding November and May, as many cable cars close and the landscape can appear transitional and dampened.
See all 3 places in The Dolomites & South Tyrol
Frequently asked questions
Which part of Italy is best for a first luxury trip?
For a first trip, Tuscany and the Amalfi Coast give the widest range of exceptional hotels within short drives. If you want quiet over spectacle, the Italian Lakes and South Tyrol score consistently higher on peace and service in guest reviews.
When is the best time to visit Italy?
Late May to mid-June and all of September combine warm weather with lower occupancy. July and August are hottest and busiest, especially on the coast.
How do you choose the Italian hotels in this collection?
Every property is selected from verified guest scores across booking platforms — we look for consistently exceptional ratings over a meaningful volume of reviews, then read what guests repeatedly say. No hotel pays to appear.
Are these hotels bookable directly?
Yes. Each property page links to the hotel's own site and its verified listings, and you can request an exclusive rate through us if you'd like help.
Which are the best hotels in Tuscany?
3 properties in Tuscany qualify for the Italy collection, ranked on this page by verified guest score weighted against how many reviews back it. Late April through June and mid-September through October. The countryside is at its best during harvest — late September to mid-October.
Which are the best hotels in the Amalfi Coast?
2 properties in the Amalfi Coast qualify for the Italy collection, ranked on this page by verified guest score weighted against how many reviews back it. Late spring and early autumn offer the most tempered weather and manageable crowds, particularly in May and September. The region becomes difficult to navigate in July and August due to intense heat and congestion, while many establishments close entirely during the quiet, damp winter months.
Which are the best hotels in Sicily?
One property in Sicily qualify for the Italy collection, ranked on this page by verified guest score weighted against how many reviews back it. Spring and early autumn offer the most temperate conditions for exploring ruins and coastal paths without the intense heat of August. The winter months can be surprisingly damp and many seasonal establishments close, while the height of summer brings heavy crowds and temperatures that may limit daytime activity.
Which are the best hotels in the Italian Lakes?
2 properties in the Italian Lakes qualify for the Italy collection, ranked on this page by verified guest score weighted against how many reviews back it. The region is at its most balanced during May and September, when the gardens are in bloom and the humidity remains low. We suggest avoiding the deep winter months of December and January, as many ferry services are suspended and the damp lakeside mist can be pervasive.
Which are the best hotels in the Dolomites & South Tyrol?
3 properties in the Dolomites & South Tyrol qualify for the Italy collection, ranked on this page by verified guest score weighted against how many reviews back it. June to September offers clear paths for hiking, while January to March provides reliable snow for the ski season. We suggest avoiding November and May, as many cable cars close and the landscape can appear transitional and dampened.
© Places You Will Love — www.placesyoulllove.com